A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF EXPENDITURE CONTROL METHODS IN GOVERNMENT AND PRIVATELY OWNED HOSPITALS. (A STUDY OF UNIVERSITY OF NIGERIA TEACHING HOSPITAL, ENUGU AND TORONTO HOSPITAL ONITSHA)

ABSTRACT

This research work on A Comparative Study of Expenditure Controls method in Government and private Hospitals is aimed at studying and analysing the different methods of expenditure control that is being adopted by these hospitals, their practical application and their level of effectiveness. It is aimed at carrying out a comparative analysis of two hospitals. To achieve the aim of this research, secondary data through textbooks and journals were used to review some of the related literatures. Equally, questionnaires, interview and observation, which sought to find out facts needed for analysing, were used. The questionnaires were analyzed by simple percentages while hypothesis were tested using chi-square statistics. The findings of the analysis indicate among others that the method of expenditure control used by both hospitals are not the same; The daily control method for private hospitals and the vote card method for Government Hospitals. The different methods of expenditure control used by the two hospitals are effective, but with slight loopholes associated with vote card method. I recommend among others that both hospitals should adhere strictly to authorization procedure for drug purchased and materials purchases. Both hospitals should exhibit high degree of cash management and employ competent personnel for proper and efficient expenditure control.

CHAPTER ONE

1.0 INTRODUCTION

1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY

Expenditure control or cost control is part of management control process, in every organisation.
This process is very important to any organisation be it profit making organisation or non-profit making organisation. Thus, lack of this practice in any organisation will cause misapplication of cash in cash disbursement process and this will create a very big problem leading the organisation into deficit and at an extreme case, the organisation might wind up. Many researches have been conducted in the reason for winding up of companies and organisation in which lack of expenditure control process had found responsible.

Expenditure control has been defined as the process by which managers utilize effectively and efficiently, the scarce resource in the achievement of the organisational goals. At this juncture, let us look at expenditure and control from separate perspective.

Expenditure is the total amount spent on the process of trying to achieve a particular organisational goal. Control means to order, limit, instruct or rule something or someone’s actions. It is used by either government officials or organisation managers to make restrictions on wages increases, immigrate credit and so on (which are all expenditure).

As regards, this research work, which is the comparative study of expenditure control methods in government and privately owned Hospitals, A study of the University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital Enugu (UNTH) and Toronto Hospital and Maternity Onitsha; this implies a comparative study of non-profit making organisations, since UNTH is government owned Hospital while Toronto Hospital is privately owned Hospital as a category of profit making organisation. Non-profit making organisations are characterized by the following:
a) There is neither a conscious profit motive nor an expectation of earning net income.
b) No profit of any excess of revenue over expenditure is distributed to those who contributed support through taxes and voluntary donations.

In profit making organisations, the reverse of these characteristics is the case in the sense that their major objective is to maximize profit and excess of revenue over expenditure are given to the owners of the organisation.
Government owned hospitals pay more attention to services they render to the public, as their major objectives is to provide services that fulfil a social needs for those who do not have the purchasing power to acquire these services themselves. Irrespective of the fact that privately owned hospitals try to render good and quality services to the public, they pay more attention to maximize of profit which their major objective.
Comparative study of expenditure control in Government and privately owned Hospital which is major research question in this research work has to with the different ways and methods by which expenditure is being controlled in each of the hospitals so that they will not run into deficit or liquidations.
According to Johnson (1976), the management control concept which imbibes the expenditure control are the same both in profit oriented and non-profit oriented organisations, but the implication of these concepts differ in important respect. We will want to find out if also the expenditure control methods are the same or differ in the two hospitals under study, owing to the fact that one is profit oriented and the other is non-profit oriented.

1.2 STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM

The problems encountered by the Government and privately owned Hospitals in expenditure control are as follows:
 The problem of daily control method and the vote card method. The problem encountered is to know the effective method to use in the two hospitals. Here, the problem encountered is to check whether the daily control method will be efficient and effective in the Government owned hospitals or whether the vote card method is the best.
 Another problem encountered by the hospitals in expenditure control is the problem of internal control. Internal control is the essential feature of an organisation, be it profit making or non-profit making, and it is expected to be well managed effectively and efficiently. Any problem or limitation of the internal control will pose a problem to the expenditure control of the organisation.
Therefore, the above problems encountered by the two hospitals are the problems of expenditure control methods encountered by the government and privately owned hospitals by the government and privately owned hospitals that attracted the attention of the researcher.

The problem definition in this research work is to investigate and analyse the different ways and methods by which expenditure is controlled in government owned hospitals and privately owned hospitals so that they will not run into deficit and liquidation. As a comparative study, two hospitals has been selected for the study, they are: University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital Enugu (UNTH) for government owned Hospitals, and Toronto Hospital and Maternity Onitsha for privately owned hospitals.
In this research, we study the different methods of expenditure control being adopted by these hospitals and their practical application and their level of effectiveness.
This study will form a basis for our analysis which will help to answer some research questions.

1.3 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

This study is conducted to:
1. Ascertain the expenditure control method adopted by the government and privately owned hospitals.
2. Establish whether government and privately owned hospitals are operating the same of different system of accounting.
3. Compare the expenditure method or model adopted by the privately owned hospitals with that of the government owned hospital if there is a difference.
4. Ascertain the efficiency and effectiveness of these expenditure control methods in the operation of the privately and government owned hospitals.
5. Make recommendations based on the findings.
1.4 RESEARCH QUESTIONS
1. What expenditure control methods are adopted in the two hospitals?
2. Do privately owned hospitals and government owned hospitals operate the same method of expenditure control?
3. Are there any similarities and differences in their method and application?
4. How efficient and effective are they to their users?

1.5 FORMULATION OF HYPOTHESIS

In this study, we will have two main types of hypothesis; the null hypothesis denoted by (H0) and Alternative hypothesis denoted by (H1). The null hypothesis is constructed such that it can be accepted if the alternative hypothesis is rejected.
Accordingly, the researcher would examine the following hypothesis.

HYPOTHESIS 1

H0: Government and privately owned hospitals do not adopt the daily control method of expenditure control.
H1: Government and privately owned hospitals adopt the daily control method of expenditure control.

HYPOTHESIS 11

H0: Government and privately owned hospitals do not use the same method of expenditure control.
8
H1: Government and privately owned hospitals uses the same methods of expenditure control

HYPOTHESIS 111

H0: The methods of expenditure control used by government and privately owned hospitals are not effective and efficient.
H1: The methods of expenditure control used by government and privately owned hospitals are effective and efficient.

1.6 SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY

Control has to be exercised over all aspect of a business organisation as a guard against any form of derailment from the organization’s objective.
Therefore, the need to install an effective and efficient expenditure control method in any organisation be it profit making or non-profit oriented cannot be over emphasised. This is because lack of this practice (expenditure control) in any organisation (profit oriented or non-oriented) will cause misapplication of cash in cash disbursement exercise. Thus may create a very high problem which may lead the organisations into deficit and in extreme cases, the organisation may wind up.

This defines why this research hopes to create awareness to management team of government and privately owned hospitals in order to put in place an effective control system.
It will also improve the various ways and methods by which expenditure are being controlled in each of the hospitals.
Being a comparative study, it will be useful to policy formulations in health related issues, hospitals management board and potential managers of the hospitals.

1.7 SCOPE OF THE STUDY

The study is on the expenditure control method on government and privately owned hospitals, as a comparative study, it will be limited to the accounting sections of the hospitals, which deals with its income and expenditure. However, other issue which has direct implication on the control aspect will be treated.

1.8 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY

Like every other research work, a lot of things posed as limitations to the research. They include:

a) Financial: The present economic constraint in the country makes it difficult for some families to feed well. Parents are faced with the difficulty of training their children, especially those who have children in the university find it difficult to pay their fees much more sponsoring the research project work. The researcher of this project is not an exception. So also, she uses the limited resources within her reach to make this research work a reality.
b) Time: The interval between chosen of project topic, the submission of the project and the preparation for the degree exams is very infinitesimal, but these are mandatory activities and hence, the researcher was deprived of many other activities to ensure their fulfilment.
c) Attitude of workers: owing to the fact that so many workers (employees) are not aware of what research is all about and its importance, they have non-challant attitude towards the researcher making it difficult for her to get the information’s needed.

1.9 DEFINITIONS OF TERMS

For the purpose of clarity, the following terms used in this context are hereby elaborated.

 Expenditure control: Management tools that guides and ensures that company/organisational spending are in accordance with the policy plans.
 Misappropriation: To steal something that you have been trusted to take care of and use it for your own personal benefit.
 Comparative study: to examine the difference between two or more things.
 Deficit: Being run at losses.
 Privately owned Hospital: Hospital owned and financed by an individual or group of people.
 Audit guidelines: These are basic principles and practices which members are expected to adhere to in the conduct of audit work.
 Government owned hospitals: Hospitals owned and controlled by government either federal or state government.
 Liquidation: To cause a business to fold up so that its assets can be sold to pay its debts.